Skip to main content
Should You Justify Yourself?
For Improv Nerds

Should You Justify Yourself?

19 November 2026 Alex Holland Alex Holland 4 min read

Being able to justify your character’s behaviour is an important skill at The FA. There are some Games that desperately need it, but there are some that work great without it ever coming up at all.  So, when do you need to justify yourself?

I’ve been teaching a few one-off workshop on Game recently. The focus has been on getting people to do what I think is the hardest part of comedy improv: not doing the funny bit.

Having the patience to leave something funny alone and wait for an opportunity to bring it up again is a hard discipline in improv!

One fall out of this is that I’ve spent less time talking about justifying and point of view, which has opened up a discussion in class. Some of the Games work great with no justification. Some of them need a little question and answer to get them off the ground.

So, when do you need to justify yourself?

What is Justifying?

Justifying is when you explain why your character is doing the thing they’re doing. It is most commonly associated with your character doing something unexpected and you needing to explain it.

The key to a good justification is to ground it in your character’s way of seeing the world, to make it into a point of view that then informs how you keep playing and making choices.

For example:

If your character wants to go to their job interview wearing a Halloween costume, a sensible question might be “Why?”

The answer to that ‘why’ is going to give you the engine for your character’s fun choices. Justifying “I love Halloween!” means you’ll execute your game differently to justifying “I want them to remember me”.

The first justification might lead you to trick or treating the interviewers, or scoffing chocolate whilst being asked questions.

The second might have you setting off a firework indoors, or leaving by jumping out the window.

NB. Remember though you want to avoid ‘rationalising’. A rationalisation might be “it’s an interview at a costume shop.” With rationalising it’s like you’re saying “my character isn’t the interesting thing, the world is”, which means you have less agency to play the Game yourself. 

In Level 3 Game at The FA we hammer justifications and point of view pretty hard. It’s a skill that helps you play Game, because comedy works best when it’s grounded in your character’s world view.

But, when I’ve been working on Game in my recent workshops, more often than not we’d skip over this stuff. Yet, we’d still have super fun and, crucially, understandable characters and Games.

Why is that? Is justifying necessary or an optional extra?

The key for me is whether we (the audience) ‘get it’.

Do We ‘Get It’?

The main point of justification is to help the audience understand so they can enjoy. If an audience is confused, they can’t laugh.

Often when we’re asking improvisers to justify, we’re actually saying “Your character has done something so unusual, we need to understand what’s going on here”. It’s a necessity to get the justification out so we can make the character playable.

Wearing a Halloween costume to a job interview is so unusual, as in it’s so unlike something the majority of people would do, that we can’t really ‘get it’ until we know why that’s happening.

But, when players are really focused on being real first and foremost, the shiny ‘funny’ moments (where the audience first laugh) are much smaller. The audience might laugh at someone preparing for a job interview and saying “God, I hope I don’t sweat”. These were the sorts of lines that got laughs when I really pushed students to play things real first and foremost. Small funny moments that came out of the reality.

Being paranoid you’re going sweat in your job interview is playable without a justification because we (the audience) understand it. We’re not going “Why would someone be worried about that?” We get it. So it’s not that it hasn’t been justified, but that the pov is so understandable it’s baked into the original shiny moment: “Nervous about job interview”. The unique additional comedic element is just “specifically about sweating”.

As the scene goes on we can push this first choice beyond reality to be sillier and more heightened - e.g. Refusing to sit anywhere but under the aircon, quickly trying to mop yourself with a flannel when the interviewers aren’t looking. But the initial move is so simple we don’t need to dissect it, we don’t need to “why?” it, we don’t need to justify.

Don’t Overdo The ‘Unusual’

Really the issue with whether to justify or not is how unusual your behaviour is. If you find you’re having to justify your behaviour with a lot of detail, maybe the initial unusual choice is too big. You’re having to work harder to make sense of it.

If your choices are coming from a real place, and you’re just listening for when something is a little bit off, you might find you don’t need to do the justifying bit. It’s already there in the way you’re playing. Now you just need to worry about finding ways to heighten it as you go.

So my rule of thumb is:

  • Do we ‘get it’? No need to justify.
  • Are we confused? Justify please.

Justifying is such a useful skill as an improviser because it means you can keep playing and grounding your behaviour in a point of view or world view. It’s something you should practise and be ready to use to help you keep making choices. But, it’s not a tick box exercise, it’s there for when you need it, and if you don’t need it because it’s already in your character, then just play.

Alex Holland
Written by

Alex Holland

Headteacher, The Free Association

Alex Holland is an award winning comedian, writer and improviser, and is headteacher at The Free Association. He's been a core part of The FA since its inception in 2014 as a cast member in the first headline shows and house teams and has been teaching advanced classes on game and forms for over a decade.

You can see him performing in It Came Out of Nowhere and Mainstage.

← All posts

Go further with improv

Done with the beginner levels? We also offer advanced classes in narrative, organic, and premise-based improv, as well as one-off workshops.

Join the waiting list

This class

This class is full. Leave your details and we'll email you if a place opens up.